Benefit of the Doubt

By a man who once shouted at a flight attendant, and would quite like to explain himself

Humanity, broadly speaking, is a disappointment. I say this as someone who has spent a great deal of time among it, on roads, in queues, in airports and in the car park of a large American supermarket on a Saturday afternoon, which is basically the Somme with trolleys.

Take driving. There is a man, and I’m fairly sure it’s the same man, who follows me everywhere in a pickup truck the size of a small cathedral. He sits eleven inches from my rear bumper at seventy miles an hour, flashing his lights as though I’ve personally insulted his mother, and when he finally overtakes he gives me a look usually reserved for people who talk in cinemas. Then he pulls in front of me, brakes for no reason, and turns off without indicating, because indicators on these trucks are apparently an optional extra, like modesty.

Then there are pedestrians. Somewhere along the line, a large portion of the population decided the correct place to stop and consult their phone is the exact middle of a doorway. Not near it. In it. They stand there like a bollard with a data plan while a queue of people builds up behind them, and if you say “excuse me” they turn round slowly, with the wounded expression of a cow that’s just been asked to move off a railway line.

And don’t get me started on people in shops. I once watched a man berate a teenage cashier for fully four minutes because a coupon had expired. The coupon was worth forty cents. He was wearing a watch that cost more than my first car. The girl stood there and took it with the thousand-yard stare of someone who knows she’s paid eleven dollars an hour and that no amount of eye contact will change that.

So yes. People are awful. I have long held this view, and I held it firmly, right up until the day I was the awful one.

A while back, my mum was taken into hospital. If you’ve had the phone call, you’ll know the one. Your stomach falls into your shoes and stays there for days. You carry on functioning, sort of, the way a car with a snapped cambelt carries on rolling for a bit after the engine’s stopped. Everything looks normal from the outside. It very much isn’t.

I was at the airport with Georgie, my dog, walking him between gates. He’s small, he’s well behaved, and he was doing what dogs do on a lead, which is walk, sniff things, and look up at me as if to ask whether we’ll be landing somewhere with squirrels.

Then a flight attendant appeared. I shan’t name the airline. I’ll just say it has a reputation for staff whose customer service style falls somewhere between a traffic warden and a nightclub bouncer, and if you knew which one I meant, I suspect we’d all be United in agreement.

He said something about Georgie. That he shouldn’t be walking. That he should be in his bag.

Now, on a normal day, I’d have said “right you are,” popped Georgie in the bag, and muttered something about jobsworths once I was safely out of earshot, which is the British way and has been since roughly 1066.

This was not a normal day.

I went off like a firework in a biscuit tin. I’m told I was quite eloquent. I’m also told I was crying, which rather undermines the eloquence. I said things to that poor man that I would not repeat to my own reflection, and I said them loudly, in a public place, in front of people eating overpriced sandwiches, who stopped chewing to watch, the way you might stop to watch a lorry reversing into a hedge.

And here’s the thing. It wasn’t really about him. He was just the one standing nearest when the dam gave way. Everything I’d been holding in since the phone call, the worry, the fear, the sheer helpless sadness of being thousands of miles and several time zones from someone you love when they’re in a hospital bed, all of it had been sitting in me like pressure in a boiler. He happened to tap the valve.

To him, I was just another rude passenger. A shouty man with a dog who didn’t like being told the rules. He’ll have gone back to the crew room and said “you’ll never guess what some lunatic did at gate twenty-three,” and everyone will have nodded and agreed that people are awful.

And he’d have been right. From where he was standing, I was awful.

Which brings me, rather uncomfortably, back to the man in the pickup truck.

Maybe he’s a nasty piece of work. Statistically, some of them must be. But maybe he’s just had a call from the school. Maybe his wife’s in labour. Maybe he’s just been told his job’s gone and he’s driving home working out how to tell his family, and every car in front of him feels like one more thing standing between him and the end of the worst day of his life.

The doorway woman might be reading a message saying her test results are back. The coupon man might have forty cents to his name and a watch he can’t bring himself to sell because it was his father’s. I don’t know. That’s the point. None of us know. We only ever see the tip of someone’s iceberg, and we judge the whole thing by the bit that’s poking out and being rude to us.

I’m not saying we should all become saints and let people drive over our feet. There are genuine idiots out there, and some of them should be put in a sack. But the next time someone snaps at you for no obvious reason, it’s worth pausing for half a second and wondering what’s going on underneath. Because one day, it’ll be you in the airport lobby, red-faced and wet-eyed, shouting at a stranger about a dog, and you’ll hope very much that somebody gives you the benefit of the doubt.

As for that flight attendant, if you’re reading this, which you won’t be, I’m sorry. You were only doing your job. Badly, and with the charm of a parking ticket, but still.

Georgie, for the record, has forgiven everyone. Dogs always do. It’s one of the many ways they’re better than us.


Thanks for dropping by my little corner of the world. If the story gave you a chuckle or made you pause and think, a like would be mighty kind. And if you’re feeling adventurous, well, hitting that subscribe button is like pulling up a chair and staying a while—always room for one more.

I subscribe back, by the way. It’s my way of saying, “Welcome to the club—snacks are in the back, good times up front!”


Your comments make me smile, sometimes laugh out loud, and every now and then, they nudge me to dig a little deeper, write a little better. So, stick around—who knows what we’ll stumble upon next.

31 responses to “Benefit of the Doubt”

  1. ibarynt Avatar

    This is food for thought. We never know what another is going through but there are also plenty of those who entitled must be their name.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. AKings Avatar

      That’s true! Those who cut you off without even using their signal light. I mean, the audacity of these people to play with their lives as well as other people’s. That always upsets me.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. midwife.mother.me. Avatar

        Not using their indicators is the least of their transgressions though! If they’d used their sodding mirrors, they’d have know you were too close for comfort. And stayed in their lane! There’s never any need for that. I can be unbelievably understanding but careless (literally without caring) driving does my head in!

        Liked by 1 person

      2. AKings Avatar

        I compete agree ☺️

        Like

  2. midwife.mother.me. Avatar

    Fear and anxiety always diminish people. And too many people are fearful, anxious or both. I’m guessing that your tears will have given the decidedly dreadful airport guy a clue that you might have been both that day… if he picked up on said clue, he’ll have forgiven you. If not, well, he should have! I see this often as a midwife where, as you can imagine, people are scared, anxious and in pain… once they see we won’t judge them, even when they behave poorly, they are much better people!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. AKings Avatar

      That’s true ☺️

      Like

  3. Pam Webb Avatar

    It is a matter of wearing the other person’s shoes, isn’t it?

    Liked by 4 people

    1. AKings Avatar

      I think so, and being the bigger person I think. 🤔

      Liked by 2 people

  4. Pleasant Street Avatar

    I like the honest way you tell your story, that we can all relate to. We have been the guy yelling, and we have been the guy being yelled at by a seeming lunatic. We don’t know what the other is going through and that knowledge makes us better, when we remember.

    How is your mum doing these days?

    Liked by 2 people

    1. AKings Avatar

      Hi. Yes that is true.
      My mum passed away last December. I was 4 hours too late….

      Like

      1. Pleasant Street Avatar

        I am so sorry. Even after I clicked send I realized that might be possible. I wish I had not brought up something more sad. I hope writing helps

        Liked by 1 person

      2. AKings Avatar

        It’s okay. Writing does help ☺️

        Liked by 1 person

  5. Ana Daksina Avatar

    Forwarded this beauty to my readers at Substack 👌

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AKings Avatar
  6. joannerambling Avatar

    Yeah I so get that when the fuse burns down anyone in the line of fire will cope it, they most likely will have no idea what the cause of the explosion was and it doesn’t matter they were there the coped the tirade from a normally sane person

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AKings Avatar

      Yeah, I wouldn’t normally do that. I’m usually a calm, smiling person ☺️.

      Like

  7. thomasstigwikman Avatar

    Yes dogs are wonderful people, people on the other hand are often not. Sometimes extreme stress makes it difficult to be polite when someone else is not. However, there are also people who act very entitled and rude unprovoked. For example, the man yelling at the young cashier, or the guy in the big truck. Even if their mother had just gotten sick or died, polite people just don’t act that way.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Ankur Mithal Avatar

    True. You don’t know the back story.

    And a nice build-up to the message.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Garrulous Gwendoline Avatar

    Telephone Customer Service Conflict Resolution 101. Rude customers are like icebergs. The behaviour they are displaying is the 10%. The trick is to get to the 90% below, commiserate with them, and then attempt to resolve with the ‘can do sandwich’, (what I can do for you is… what I can’t do is… so – would you like me to go ahead and do that “xyz” thing that you can do).
    Sigh, taking me back a couple of decades to my team training days…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AKings Avatar

      Oh, now I’ve got some insider info ☺️

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Garrulous Gwendoline Avatar

        It’s good for diffusing a situation. Think of how many times you’ve called an organisation with a concern or complaint, expecting that they will blame you for it, or do nothing. You’re already riled up before “hello”. So, the faster we can get to what the issue is, say “I’d be frustrated too if that happened to me” (or words to that effect), then steer the conversation to what the customer would like done to fix the problem, the better. My team was in an open plan environment. They all got good at it, just by overhearing their colleague next to them. Gosh! I miss that team. They were so good! (at all their jobs).

        Liked by 1 person

      2. AKings Avatar

        Sounds like they were ☺️. It’s an art form ☺️.

        Liked by 1 person

  10. Joni Avatar

    Well written……everyone loses it once in awhile, and there’s usually something tragic behind it. I had a customer tear a strip off one of my assistants one day, and it turned out later, that she was just coming from a funeral. But…..what if the person is always rude? Some people are just all around miserable unhappy beings… I hate those big monster trucks as they take up too much parking space, and they always want to pass you when you’re going the speed limit. One passed me on a snowy stretch of road, did a complete spin around and ended up in the ditch. He was okay, so I waved as I drove past.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AKings Avatar

      The only thing you can do is wave I guess, after all, he’s the one with the bigger truck 😂.

      Liked by 1 person

  11. shredbobted Avatar

    I was gonna ask how Georgie did in the whole ordeal. They’re so sensitive to us. I’ve been on both ends too, I actually kinda have the thousand yard stare today. I don’t know if it was the woman whose phone order I took too slow to please her first thing when we opened, or the people who asked me where to find a pop-up weed party, or the end of the day when we got busy (of course) and there was no way to keep up and someone wanted to yell at my wife for not getting to him fast enough. (We work together. Have for thirty years. But knowing someone is angry with your wife for something she can’t help is hard.)

    Dealing with the public is very difficult.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AKings Avatar

      Georgie is very sensitive with my feelings, he knows and he gets upset. But when he does he gets quiet.
      Must be tough dealing with the public especially when your wife is there too! You guys are tough ☺️.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. shredbobted Avatar

        Gratitude in gratitude out!

        Liked by 1 person

  12. Bronlima Avatar

    Eceryone has their moment. It is understandable. But some people have their moment……. every moment. What is it? What to they gain from it except misery. Some people see the doughnut, others see the hole. Personally I simply prefer to eat it!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AKings Avatar

      That sounds philosophical 😊

      Like

  13. Balders Avatar

    A really good read. Well said and love to Georgie 👍

    Like

Leave a Reply